BDS Avatar?

The best BDS hoax story yet has just arrived from Canada, causing one of those truly “you can’t make this stuff up!” moments.

I spent much of last year chronicling the tendency of boycott and divestment activists to make fraudulent claims of victory, from the academic hoax at Hampshire, to false claims that the financial firms Blackrock or TIAA-CREF or companies like Motorola had made financial decisions for political reasons.

More recently, the forging of signatures on boycott petitions made its debut in the UK, so it was just a matter of time before this practice found its way to North America.

The story actually begins last Fall when a relatively obscure Canadian film maker, John Greyson (also a teacher at York University), pulled his work from the Toronto Film Festival in protest of that festival’s inclusion of movies from Tel Aviv in their celebration of international urban cinema. This action was accompanied by a petition declaring the festival was, in effect, celebrating Tel Aviv and thus the brutality of “The Occupation,” the suffering of Palestinians in Gaza who struggle to live while Tel Avivians make movies, blah, blah, blah.

This non-story got some ink when a collection of celebrities (including Jane Fonda) signed onto the petition, with some of them (again, Jane Fonda) eventually signing off. As usual, supporters of Israel rallied, the press railed at this attempt at censorship masquerading as artistic “solidarity” and Israeli films were the hit of the Festival.

Flash forward to 2010 when a new petition began circulating around film schools asking them to not participate in this June’s Tel Aviv Student Film Festival because (you know the drill).

The letter itself is worthy of dissection as an example of mental gymnastics (trying to portray an unambiguous attempt to punish a country by boycotting its film makers as something other than the shunning of artists in the name of someone else’s politics). But the real interesting part of the story is the signature section which features none other than “The King of the World” himself: James Cameron.

Now (as far as I know) the Canadian-born Cameron has never had a word to say about the Arab-Israeli conflict, and his name on such a letter would certainly represent a coup for boycott promoters. If it was real. Which it’s not.

As near as I can tell (and details are still coming in) this letter was initiated (and/or promulgated) by the same people involved with Toronto Film Fest boycott fiasco. Supposedly a press conference on the matter was scheduled for today, but was mysteriously called off. This may just have something to do with the fact that someone who saw the letter contacted Cameron’s people and discovered he not only didn’t sign the document, but he’s never seen it and is demanding answers as to how his name got onto such a letter.

In short, the hoaxers who seemed to be trying to leverage famous names to give their project credibility now face the wrath of one of the world’s richest and most powerful film makers. Forgive me a little shadenfreude, but what I would give to be in the home/apartment/dormroom/studio of those who thought they could get away with such an obviously exposable fraud.

I’ll post more details on the story as they become available, but we seem to have clearly entered an age when the sheer scale of BDS failure after a decade of so much intense effort has left boycott and divestment advocates somewhat unhinged. That, or they simply continue to believe that their self-righteous fury allows them to do absolutely anything, even if (or especially if) it involves treating the public (or, in this case, peers in the film making world) like absolute idiots.

, , , , , , , , ,

6 Responses to BDS Avatar?

  1. Happy and Proud February 7, 2010 at 2:03 am #

    This is typical of the BDS crowd; when their efforts to delegitimatize Israel fail (because almost no one agrees with them), they just make something up and call it a “victory”. They did this with a New York labor leader, the Red Cross, and now James Cameron.

    Not one of the above agreed with the BDS agenda, the BDS claims were nothing more than a fraud perpetrated on those whose name implies respectability. It just proves once again that the entire BDS 'movement' is based on lies.

  2. Abu Justice February 7, 2010 at 6:55 pm #

    We will keep fighting for BDS until Israel conforms to International law. If it takes a generation or more, Fine. I am teaching my children.

  3. Anonymous February 8, 2010 at 4:07 pm #

    Far from signing on to to something like this, Cameron is a friend and colleague of Simcha Jacobovici, the Canadian-Israeli filmmaker who now lives in Israel. they made “The Exodus Decoded” together. I know Simcha well enough to know that if Cameron was the boycotting type, he'd never work with the guy in a million years

  4. Rebecca February 8, 2010 at 11:09 pm #

    Abu Justice, what a clever name. Why not try working for peace instead?

  5. Jon February 9, 2010 at 1:41 am #

    Dear Abu J – You are, of course, free to raise your children in any way you wish. I would, however, suggest you think about how well it's gone for each successive generation of Palestians who have chosen to follow the path you are choosing for your own children of teaching the lesson of bitter rejection (masquarading as justice). You may want to consider whether you are giving them a legacy or a curse before going down the road so many bitter foes of Israel have tread before.


  1. Divest This! | BlazingCatFur - September 25, 2014

    […] Heh;)… […]

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes